Skip to content

Modifications and retrofit

Substantial modification: when whoever modifies a machine becomes its manufacturer

What a substantial modification is under Machinery Regulation 2023/1230, software included, and what it means for integrators, retrofitters and anyone modifying machinery after sale.

Resources · Updated on · 5 min read

In short

Under Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 a substantial modification is a physical or digital modification, not foreseen by the manufacturer, made after placing on the market, that creates a new hazard or increases an existing risk. Whoever makes it is considered the manufacturer for the modified part, with the related obligations of assessment, documentation and declaration. It concerns integrators, retrofitters and whoever updates safety software.

What a substantial modification is

According to the sources we consulted, it is a modification:

  • physical or digital, so a software update counts too;
  • not foreseen by the original manufacturer;
  • made after placing on the market or putting into service;
  • that creates a new hazard or increases an existing risk, making new protective measures necessary.

What is new compared with the Directive is that the definition is written into the Regulation and explicitly includes digital modifications.

Who it concerns

  • Integrators who combine several machines or partly completed machines into a line.
  • Retrofit companies that modernise existing machinery.
  • Users who modify a machine in-house, for example by changing guards or safety logic.
  • Whoever updates software that affects safety functions.

What it entails

Whoever makes a substantial modification takes on the obligations of the manufacturer, for the modified part or for the whole machine if the modification affects all of it: risk assessment, technical documentation, updated instructions, declaration and marking. It is always worth assessing the case with a CE consultant.

Why tracking versions per serial number pays off

When a machine is modified years after sale, the first question is: what was originally delivered? Having for each serial number the version of the manual, the configuration and the history of the safety software helps both the original manufacturer and whoever modifies it to separate responsibilities.

In TARGA every serial number has its publication and software history, and the manufacturer chain links later incorporations and substantial modifications.

Frequently asked questions

Can a software update be a substantial modification?

Yes. The Regulation also covers digital modifications. If the update is not foreseen by the manufacturer and creates a new hazard or increases a risk, it can be a substantial modification.

Does a retrofitter always become the manufacturer?

Not always: it depends on whether the modification falls under the definition of substantial modification. If it does, whoever makes it takes on the obligations of the manufacturer. It must be assessed case by case with a consultant.

This article is for information only and is not legal or technical advice. Always check the official text of the Regulation on EUR-Lex and with a qualified consultant. For the big picture read the Machinery Regulation 2027 guide.

Country by country

Mandatory languages, national law and penalties in the countries where you sell:

Start today

Put your machine documentation in order

14-day free trial, no credit card required. Or see how it works with sample data.

Substantial modification of machinery: when you become the manufacturer · TARGA